Max Confusion: What HBO's Branding Flip-Flop Can Teach Us
Not every brand misstep is obvious right away.
This is a case study in brand clarity lost, and (maybe) regained.
It's about how trust gets built, how it can get blurred, and what we can all learn when a brand walks too far from its core.
The Timeline of a Misstep:
- 2008: HBO Go
- 2015: HBO Now
- 2020: HBO Max
- 2023: Max
- 2025: Back to HBO Max
That’s a lot of name changes. And while each came with a strategic reason, there was one big problem: “Max” had no equity, no story, and no memory. Just a vague promise of “more.”
But “HBO”? That meant something: Prestige, quality, storytelling, you name it. A brand people trusted to deliver. And when that name vanished, so did the clarity.
What Most Brands Get Wrong:
- They treat the name as decoration: Your name is a shortcut to trust, a signal. Removing what people know and love doesn’t open new doors… it closes the old ones.
- They confuse expansion with dilution: Yes, you might be offering more. But more what? More confusion doesn’t equal more connection.
- They move too fast: Just because you’re bored with your branding doesn’t mean your audience is. Strong brands evolve. They don’t disappear.
A loving observer of the intersection between creativity and strategy
What We Can Learn:
Clarity > Clever.
“Max” may have sounded modern, but clarity is better than cool, always. If your audience has to ask what your brand is, you’ve already lost them.
Trust is your true differentiator.
When HBO was removed from the name, so was the emotional anchor. People didn’t know what to expect anymore. That’s a trust gap, and it showed.
Going back isn’t failure. It’s leadership.
Admitting the rebrand didn’t work and returning to HBO Max? That’s not backtracking. That’s listening and demonstrating that your audience's voice matters.
Quick Brand Clarity Roadmap:
If you're navigating a rebrand or just feeling unsure about your identity, here’s where to start:
- Audit what’s working.
What parts of your name, design, or story still connect deeply with your audience?
- Ask your audience.
What do they actually think of your brand today? What do they trust you for?
- Clarify your core.
What are the 2–3 truths your brand should always stand for, no matter how it evolves?
- Evolve with intention.
Don’t change to look busy. Change when it brings you closer to what your audience needs most.
- Keep consistency sacred.
Messaging, tone, visuals, and alignment across every touchpoint build memory and trust.
What We Believe at PVG:
At Pura Vida Growth, branding should feel like coming home, not like trying to guess the Wi-Fi password. Your brand should be clear, consistent, and deeply rooted in what initially made people care.
So before you rebrand, rename, or reinvent, pause. Ask what’s really driving the change. And make sure your audience won’t feel lost when you move forward.
Because bold brands don’t confuse people. They connect with them.
Is your brand clarity drifting? Let’s take a look together.
Keep pushing. Keep dreaming. Keep delivering.
.svg){kind=small}